I propose to *remove* a feature, that lies at the core of many usability and design problems: the task state Postponed (aka "Moved" or "Scheduled").
# What are Noteplan's task states?
A task in NP3 has five task states:
- *inactive*: task I might want to do, but haven't yet committed to do.
- *open*: task I decided to do
- *completed*: task I actually did
- *canceled*: task I decided *not* to do at all
- *postponed*: task I decided *not* to do today, but decided to postpone to another date *and* keep a record of my decision.
# How do other apps handle this case?
I'm not aware of any other digital task management tool that keeps such a record of postponement decisions.
# What is the downside of this fifth state?
It creates ambiguous syntax and confuses [terminology](https://noteplan.canny.io/task-management/p/wording-more-sys…).
In regular notes `>YYYY-MM-DD` *assigns a date* to open/completed/cancelled tasks. In regular notes it indicates when *this* (only) copy of the task is to be done. Example:
Task in regular note `shopping.md` reminds me to buy groceries on April 24th:
```
- [ ] Buy groceries >2021-04-24
```
In daily notes `>YYYY-MM-DD` *links* a postponed task to a more recent copy of the task. It indicates where *another* copy of the task might be found that is to be done. Example:
This copy of the task in daily note `20210423.md` reminds me, that I wanted to go shopping on April 23rd, but postponed it to April 24th:
```
- [>] Buy groceries >2021-04-24
```
This copy of the same task reminds me also, that I wanted to go shopping on April 23rd, but postponed it to April 24th, but it is located in daily note `20210424.md`:
```
- [ ] Buy groceries <2021-04-23
```
Rescheduling even the most trivial task creates copies and adds clutter.
# What is won, when the fifth state is gone?
Less clutter. Less ambiguity. Simpler user interface. A task manager that behaves like other task managers.
When a task is postponed in a daily note, the task is literally *moved* verbatim from one text file to another. It looks the same after it was rescheduled. It's just in a different daily note:
```
- [] Buy groceries
```
And it it would look exactly the same, if it were *moved* to/from a regular note.
Eliminating this task state requires *eliminating all functionality that depends on it*. This process requires some planning, but it would resolve many contradictions and inconsistencies in the design. It would make Noteplan so much simpler to use and explain.
# What is lost?
Some users might miss the schedule-by-copy action. Maybe because they got used to it, maybe because they need it. If there are really users, who need a trace of their postponement decisions, I'd like to hear from you!
Edit: This task state is necessary for features that some users really enjoy. Complete removal would go too far. But why not make it optional? https://noteplan.canny.io/task-management/p/user-preference-…